Yes I know it’s April Fool’s Day but I don’t think these people were fooling.
I just read two-thirds of the latest Chapter 1 to the Coventry Writer’s group and two of them said it was much better than before, that it was creepy and had good imagery and other positive things. They had both heard earlier versions and had never been so positive about any of them. In fact I don’t remember ever getting such positive responses.
One member said he liked it but had to leave before giving any more feedback.
The other two were more critical. One said he thought the characters were two-dimensional and that the emotion was told not shown. The other thought the pink planets were hard to imagine.
I accept these criticisms but they do not worry me. You don’t get time to paint rounded characters in this space as well as describing the environment. The first two people disagreed too, saying they found Michael creepy, not flat.
As for the imagery, I know it can be difficult to visualise, since I’m describing a fairly un-worldly scene. I guess some readers will need to read it a couple of times to get the picture. That’s life.
In general I left the meeting fairly elated, and feeling that, after six years of effort, I’m finally heading in the right direction. If I can keep up that standard I just may have a hit!


